Second Team All Conference
| Last Name | First Name | Year | Class | Position |
| Bouska | Joey | 2021 | Junior | OF |
| Bormann | Garrett | 2020 | Senior | IF |
| Obermueller | Cade | 2020 | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| Kuepker | Zach | 2019 | Senior | OF |
| Dykes | Jacob | 2018 | Senior | 1B |
| Heck | DJ | 2018 | Junior | Outfield |
| Deshler | Dylan | 2017 | Senior | Outfield |
| Reyhons | Travis | 2017 | Junior | Infield |
| Fellows | Griffin | 2016 | Senior | Outfield |
| Ringen | Nile | 2016 | Senior | First Base |
| Frantz | Bryce | 2015 | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| Hensley | Matt | 2015 | Senior | Outfield |
| McCleary | Brett | 2015 | Sophomore | Infield |
| Ringen | Nile | 2014 | Sophomore | Utility |
| Crosby | Josh | 2013 | Senior | Outfield |
| Stika | Tyler | 2013 | Senior | Catcher |
| Frakes | Jack | 2012 | Junior | Infield |
| Stika | Tyler | 2012 | Junior | Catcher |
| Wieland | Mitch | 2012 | Sophomore | Utility |
| Duncan | Ryan | 2011 | Junior | Outfield |
| Hamm | Brent | 2011 | Senior | Infielder |
| Alberhasky | Connor | 2010 | Junior | Utility |
| Derby | AJ | 2009 | Senior | |
| Derby | AJ | 2008 | Junior | Infielder |
| Harney | Drew | 2008 | Outfield | |
| Maxwell | Chris | 2007 | ||
| Schmidt | Ted | 2007 | Pitcher | |
| Greenwald | Jeff | 2004 | ||
| Kennedy | Ryan | 2004 | ||
| Barnes | Joel | 2002 | ||
| Deal | Greg | 2002 | ||
| Smith | Jacob | 2002 | ||
| Wooldrik | Matt | 1999 | ||
| Hobart | Josh | 1998 | ||
| Kindhart | Ryan | 1998 | ||
| Linder | Nick | 1998 | ||
| Shields | Mickey | 1998 | ||
| Hill | Kahlil | 1997 | ||
| Hurley | Kevin | 1997 | ||
| Sahler | Tim | 1997 |
