First Team All Conference
| Last Name | First Name | Year | Class | Position | |
| Klosterman | John | 2021 | Junior | Utility | |
| Mitchell | Gable | 2021 | Junior | Infield | |
| Obermueller | Cade | 2021 | Junior | Pitcher | |
| Seaton | Carter | 2021 | Junior | Infield | |
| Mitchell | Gable | 2020 | Sophomore | Infield | |
| Seaton | Carter | 2020 | Sophomore | Utility | |
| McComas | Liam | 2019 | Senior | Utility | |
| Reyhons | Travis | 2018 | Senior | Infield | |
| McCleary | Brett | 2017 | Senior | Pitcher | |
| Sass | Caleb | 2017 | Senior | Infield | |
| Stone | Zach | 2017 | Senior | Utility | |
| Frantz | Bryce | 2016 | Junior | Pitcher | |
| Leigh | Dylan | 2016 | Senior | Infield | |
| McCleary | Brett | 2016 | Junior | Catcher | |
| Sueppel | Nick | 2015 | Senior | Catcher | |
| Wieland | Mitch | 2013 | Junior | Infield | |
| Crosby | Josh | 2012 | Junior | First Base | |
| Duncan | Ryan | 2012 | Senior | Outfield | |
| Mrstik | Sam | 2012 | Junior | Infield | |
| Alberhasky | Connor | 2011 | Senior | Pitcher | |
| Prybil | Adam | 2011 | Senior | First Base | |
| Prybil | Adam | 2010 | Junior | First Base | |
| Derby | AJ | 2009 | Junior | Infield | |
| Prybil | Adam | 2009 | Sophomore | Outfielder | |
| McCreedy | Tyler | 2008 | Senior | Catcher | |
| Schmidt | Ted | 2008 | Senior | Pitcher | |
| Smith | Colton | 2008 | Senior | Outfield | |
| Morelock | Shane | 2007 | Junior | Outfield | |
| Spencer | Alex | 2007 | Senior | Catcher | |
| Alberhasky | Ryan | 2006 | Senior | Utility | |
| Evans | Ben | 2006 | Senior | Outfield | |
| Gilmore | Jonathan | 2006 | Junior | Infield | |
| Butler | Jack | 2005 | Senior | Pitcher | |
| Gilmore | Jonathan | 2005 | Sophomore | Infield | |
| Jones | Keaton | 2005 | Senior | Catcher | |
| Muhlenbruch | Nick | 2005 | Senior | Infield | |
| Gilmore | Jonathan | 2004 | Freshman | Infield | |
| Muhlenbruch | Nick | 2004 | Junior | Utility | |
| Smith | Cody | 2004 | Senior | Outfield | *** |
| Barnes | Joel | 2003 | Senior | Utility | |
| Smith | Cody | 2003 | Junior | Outfield | |
| Jostes | Connor | 2002 | Senior | Infield | |
| Wooldrik | Matt | 2002 | Senior | Outfield | |
| Gilmore | Jeff | 2001 | Senior | Infield | |
| Kesselring | Kyle | 2001 | Senior | First Base | |
| Maxwell | Matt | 2001 | Senior | Infield | |
| Wooldrik | Matt | 2001 | Junior | Outfield | |
| Frahm | Eric | 2000 | Senior | Outfield | |
| Furlong | Brian | 2000 | Senior | Pitcher | |
| Furlong | Brian | 1999 | Junior | Utility | |
| Gilmore | Jeff | 1999 | Sophomore | Infield | |
| Kindhart | Ryan | 1999 | Junior | Pitcher | |
| Linder | Nick | 1999 | Senior | Catcher | |
| Moss | Skyler | 1999 | Sophomore | First Base | |
| Colangelo | Joe | 1998 | Junior | Outfield | |
| Gilmore | Jeff | 1998 | Freshman | Infield | |
| Sahler | Tim | 1998 | Senior | Pitcher | |
| Akre | Eric | 1997 | Senior | Utility | |
| Price | Mitch | 1997 | Senior | Pitcher | |
| Seaton | Mark | 1997 | Senior | Catcher | |
| Heefner | Dan | 1996 | Senior | Infield | |
| Price | Mitch | 1996 | Junior | Pitcher | |
| Seaton | Mark | 1996 | Junior | Catcher | |
| Gavin | Patrick | 1995 | Senior | Pitcher | |
| Grabinski | Zach | 1995 | Senior | First Base | |
| Loria | Jeremy | 1995 | Senior | Catcher | |
| Mitchell | Brian | 1995 | Senior | Infield | *** |
| Grabinski | Zach | 1994 | Junior | First Base | |
| Loria | Jeremy | 1994 | Junior | Catcher | |
| Mitchell | Brian | 1994 | Junior | Infield | |
| Seaton | Brad | 1994 | Senior | Outfield | |
| Hamdorf | Chris | 1993 | Senior | Outfield | |
| Mayer | Travis | 1993 | Senior | Pitcher | |
| Thieleke | CJ | 1993 | Senior | Infield | |
| Hanrahan | Adam | 1992 | Senior | Outfield | |
| Palmer | Ethan | 1992 | Junior | Utility | |
| Thieleke | CJ | 1992 | Junior | Infield |
